Why Moving a Bill to a Budget Item Can Become Undemocratic

It Avoids Debate and Transparency

Billsgo through public hearings, debates, and amendments — allowingcitizens, experts, and advocatesto weigh in.

Abudgetis often passed quickly and in bulk, limiting discussion on individual items.

Example: A controversial education bill might fail on its own, but when buried in a massive budget, it slides through without full scrutiny.

It Limits Public Voice

People expectseparate lawsto be debated and voted on openly.

When something is added as a line in the budget,voters and watchdogs may not even noticeit’s there.

It Concentrates Power

This tactic can allow a few lawmakers — often behind closed doors — to make decisions that would normally requirefull legislative and public participation.

It’s a Shortcut to Avoid Accountability

Moving a policy into the budget is sometimes used tosneak in laws that wouldn’t survivethe normal democratic process.

In short:It’s not inherently illegal, but when misused, it underminesdemocratic principles of openness, fairness, and public input.